Key West

Angelina’s Pizzeria

Angelina Pizzeria has been serving the freshest pizza in the heart of Old Key West, FL on Duval Street for over 30 years. We hand make our pizza crust daily and all our dishes are packed with flavor, delicious and ready for lunch, dinner or after a full night of Key West festivities. Come down and grab a slice and taste for yourself!


out our









The Best Piece In Town!

Order Online

Quick and easy online ordering!

Dine In or Carry Out

Come dine with us or carryout!

Fast Delivery

Fresh pizza delivered to your door!

Since 1988

Kit Carson Smith, Angelina’s founder and Pizza Master, grew up in a rural Georgia town and paid his way through college at Troy University bartending and honing his skills in the hospitality trade, making lots of friends and eating a lot of pizza along the way. After college he found himself in Key West, working at Rick;s and enjoying the island life. He never dreamed he’s someday own the coolest pizza joint in Key West, but when the opportunity surfaced he grabbed it and began building what is today fondly known all over the country and possibly the world as “The Best Piece in Town”!


“Spinning pizza dough has its perks. A few years back, I met a driving rep from the Kelly Moss Porsche racing team. Now, I have my pizza art on the side of a beautiful orange Porsche that blazes around the track at over 150 miles per hour! When we get the opportunity, we ride up to the track and party with the race team. We even have our dry fit shirts in the shop for purchase. You can also get them online soon!”

"Whenever I visit the track, everyone refers to me as ‘Pizza Man.’ The social aspect of food and how it brings people together has enriched my life with human beings from all over the world, from all walks of life. I was lucky enough to have met a beautiful woman who became my wife while spinning dough one night. Who can say that? So, whether you’re a regular or a new customer, you're family here.”

Come see Us!

Situated in close proximity to most of Key West’s most popular resorts and hotels, Angelina’s Pizza is the perfect choice any time of day. Whether you’re looking for late night delivery to your hotel or hoping to grab a quick snack on your way to sunset at Mallory Square, Angelina’s is the way to go! Take advantage of our arcade games and check out our turtle pond while you wait or  experience some of the best people watching while enjoying pizza with friends and family!

208 Duval Street Key West FL 33040

(305) 296-3600

Hours Of Operation

Open 11:00am – 3:30am

Delivery 11:00am – 2:30am


(305) 296-3600