Welcome to Angelina’s Pizzeria

For over three decades, Angelina’s Pizzeria has been the go-to destination for the freshest and most mouthwatering pizza in the heart of Old Key West, FL, conveniently located on the oh so vibrant Duval Street. With our unwavering commitment to quality, we handcraft our pizza crust daily, ensuring a perfect foundation for your favorite pizza. Whether you’re seeking a satisfying lunch, a delightful dinner, or a post-night-out treat after reveling in Key West’s vibrant festivities, Angelina Pizzeria is the place to be!

Over three decades ago, a pizza paradise was born at the bustling corner of Greene and Duval, just across from Sloppy Joe’s in the Rick’s/Durty Harry’s complex. Today, we continue to reign as the ultimate pizza destination in town, serving up perfection year-round, seven days a week, from 11:00 am until the early hours of the morning! Before bidding farewell to this enchanting island, ensure you make one last stop at Angelina’s to savor a slice of pizza heaven and complete your unforgettable Key West nightlife experience. Whether you opt for a single slice, a full pizza, a salad, sandwich, or a mouthwatering pasta dish, rest assured that you’re indulging in homemade goodness